I criticize Feministe a lot, not because I don't like the site or Jill, but because I do. Because there is immense potential there, and I always end up disappointed. Though I will say that it isn't Feministe alone, but something more symptomatic of liberal and progressive spaces overall -- the sense that racism (as well as transphobia, sexism, classism, ableism, homophobia) can't exist here because we're good liberals; we've unpacked all our privileges.
Lauren, who started Feministe back in the early 2000s, left a lengthy comment apologizing for her exclusion of WOC (as well as others who don't fit the straight, white, able-bodied, middle-class template), and her involvement with HS, which is admirable, but incomplete. She says:
I would have liked to see during the “Full Frontal/Jungle” fight was some feminist bloggers writing explicit guides to up and coming writers — particularly non-traditional writers, say, who hadn’t gone to college or who were home with children or who lacked some of the illustrious friendships, resumes, and connections that would serve as a professional stepping stool — about how to break into the publishing world, write a book proposal, shop for and secure an agent, create a portfolio, create professional social media presences, submit to brick and mortar publishing institutions, and make this process more open and transparent for all instead of guarding trade secrets.I don't think this is a bad per se -- it's good to share resources -- but it still trades in the idea that feminism is capitalism. Maybe I'm just a hippy socialist, but it seems disingenuous. And the "we need to help them because obviously they can't help themselves" talk is pretty othering.
On a personal note, I'm trying to make an effort to be more vocal in the actual community rather than from the relative safety of my own blog. I see too much happening and say nothing, in part because I feel alienated by feminism, too, but that doesn't make it any less hypocritical.
There are, of course, socialist feminists. but if feminism were socialism, then I couldn't be a feminist -- which would make no sense to me.
ReplyDeleteTMH, I think equating feminism with socialism is a first-world thing. People in the developing world have experienced its failures and know better.