Also, I think we need to make the distinction between the long-standing, multi-generational class oppression and the temporary kind that comes with being new to the workforce and heavy in debt with student loans. I'm not saying those things aren't important -- and as the occupy movement has show, that line is becoming thinner and thinner -- but the face of the feminist blogosphere in particular is white, middle-class and college educated.
I've largely stayed away from the discussion at hand, but I really wanted to highlight this comment from Feministe commenter Shelly:
It seems this site is a community only for educated, white, urban, coastal women in the USA and a handful of women in other countries who are similarly situated. Also they have to know feminist theory and the proper lingo. If not, their voices don’t matter.Granted, I hit a few of these markers myself, but I’m not coastal (I live in a conservative part of the country), I’m not middle-class, and what feminist theory I have has been acquired piecemeal — as in I’ve never taken a formal women’s or gender studies course — but I’m pretty well-read. It’s not like I don’t know this stuff. and frankly, I find it a little insulting that the only way to familiarize oneself with feminist theory and the “proper” lingo is to take a class, but I think it's sometimes easy to forget that not everyone has access to the same resources. I rarely comment, not necessarily for those reasons, but that the minute I identify myself as working-class, my words will be interpreted as less than sophisticated.
So where's the solution when class bias is so deeply woven into progressive circles -- the kind of bias that says "thank goodness they aren't me?" We might not be you, but we're reading you.
No comments:
Post a Comment